A Nostalgic Depiction of a Horrific Experience
“It’s still there. Under the skin. It’s good for a story, something to shock people with after I’ve known them for years and feel a need to surprise them with the other boy” (Whitehead 191). Colson Whitehead’s depiction of the BB gun incident is anything but pleasant. He describes, clinically, Benji's desperate attempts to cut the skin open with razor blades to extract a BB shot into his eye socket. Yet, for all its brutality, the scene is tinged with a kind of strange and nostalgic haze, like a movie flashback viewed through yellowed glass. It feels as though Ben is looking back at his younger self, Benji, with a kind of affection, savoring the memory despite its pain. Sag Harbor is littered with nostalgic recounts of events that happened in Benji’s summer town on Long Island. In this specific instance, it is clear that the current day Ben has very little to do with the Benji that we spend the whole book learning. Ben only reveals the "other boy" to people he has know...